Montana Free Press

Election 2024 Guide

Montana's candidates for state and federal office.

A digital project by |
Last update: Jun 24, 2024
All RacesFederal DelegationState OfficialsMontana LegislatureOther officesBallot InitiativesVoting info
Elsie Arntzen
Montana Republican candidate
for U.S. House District 2 (East)

Elsie Arntzen

State superintendent of public instruction

Active candidates for U.S. House District 2 (East)

General election nominees were selected via the June 4, 2024, primary election.

Republican

Arntzen, 68 as of Election Day, has served as Montana’s top elected public education official for the past eight years. A former teacher, she was born in Billings and represented Billings-area seats in the state Legislature from 2005 to 2017.

As Arntzen campaigns this year, she describes herself as a staunch “America First” conservative who will stand up for families and Montana values in Congress.

“America is fed up, and we cannot continue to saddle our children and grandchildren with the problems we need to tackle today,” she said.

Arntzen was cited in May 2022 for an incident where she allegedly drove past a school bus with its stop lights deployed, ultimately paying a $135 fine.

This biography is based on written materials submitted by Arntzen’s campaign, as well as MTFP reporting.

Want original Montana Free Press reporting and analysis sent to your inbox each week?
Sign up for the free MT LOWDOWN newsletter
Delivered Friday afternoons

ON THE ISSUES

Answers here were solicited from candidates via a written questionnaire conducted by MTFP in April 2024. Responses were limited to 1,000 characters and edited lightly for punctuation and spelling. Candidates were asked to focus on the positives their service would bring the state instead of making rhetorical attacks on their opponents. Responses have not been exhaustively fact-checked.

What do you regard as the biggest issue Montana is facing that Congress is in a position to address? How would you address it if elected or re-elected?
Elsie Arntzen:

Federal government overreach, overspending and irresponsibility are destroying the country. The Biden administration has failed to secure our border and is allowing illegal migrants to overrun our nation and threaten our national security. The number of illegal aliens that entered our country under Biden is six times Montana’s population.

Our national debt is crushing our families and children by exacerbating inflation and making everyday goods inaccessible. The bureaucracy is attacking our way of life with burdensome regulations. As a member of the Land Board, I fiercely protected Montanans personal property and water rights. I promise to reign in the overreaching regulations of the Bureau of Land Management.

The federal government is out of control and is damaging the American dream for Montanans. We must put America first. That means protecting our borders, supporting Montanan farmers, ranchers, and small business owners, and not saddling our future generations with crushing debt.

Compare to competing candidates
Can you name a current member of Congress you admire? What do respect about them?
Elsie Arntzen:

I admire Congresswoman Harriet Hageman, who took out RINO Liz Cheney. Congresswoman Hageman isn’t afraid to tackle tough issues and champions issues that are important to Montanans. She wants to return education back to the states by dismantling the Department of Education. The congresswoman supports property and water rights and is fighting to make America energy independent.

I also admire Congressman Matt Rosendale and many of the House Freedom Caucus (HFC) members who have led the way to get federal spending under control. I am honored to have the endorsement of the HFC chairman, Congressman Bob Good, and other members such as Congressmen Andy Biggs, Eli Crane, Mary Miller, Troy Nehls and Josh Brecheen. I also have the endorsements of Montana Freedom Caucus members Sen. John Fuller, Sen. Steve Hinebauch, Sen. Dan Bartel, Rep. Jerry Schillinger and Rep. Bob Phalen. These members endorsed me because I will fight for conservative values, cut spending, and put America first.

Compare to competing candidates
If President Joe Biden is re-elected, how would you want to work with his administration as a congressman?
Elsie Arntzen:

I would happily work with anyone who wants to put America first, secure our border and prioritize prosperity for our citizens. I also would welcome an invitation to the White House to enlighten Biden on how his reckless policies have hurt Montanans and all Americans. Hopefully, the administration would change its position on the border, the economy, energy and many other policy areas.

Biden’s most recent sweeping changes to the Department of Education Title IX rules creates a one-size-fits-all policy that removes any local input into our schools with a radically woke redefinition of sex. This rule threatens women-only spaces and women’s sports. That is why I submitted a public comment opposing this rule when it was first proposed. As superintendent of public instruction, I directed schools to not implement these changes, and I will continue to fight against this destructive change to Title IX with Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen.

Compare to competing candidates
Similarly, if former President Donald Trump is elected, how would you want to work with him?
Elsie Arntzen:

I would work with President Trump to secure our border, return energy independence, unleash economic potential of small businesses and put America First. President Trump is America’s best chance to get back on track to protect the American dream. That is why I was the first in this congressional race to endorse him.

Together, President Trump and I will work to drain the swamp of the entrenched bureaucrats who unfairly target Montana families, ranchers and farmers. The southern border will be secured to stop the flow of dangerous cartels who poison our communities with fentanyl. Since 2017 there has been an increase of 1,900% in fentanyl deaths in Montana. America will once again be energy independent when Montana leads the way in accessing the abundance of natural resources our country possesses. President Trump and I will unleash the economic potential of Americans, and our global enemies will respect and fear us. Once again, we will have leadership that puts America first.

Compare to competing candidates
Do you regard reining in the federal deficit as a priority? If so, in what budget areas would you support spending cuts or tax increases?
Elsie Arntzen:

America’s debt problem is the biggest threat facing our nation. The government has a spending problem, not a taxing problem. Our debt is currently over $34 trillion dollars, that is more than $103,000 for every citizen. U.S. interest payments will hit $870 billion this year — that is more than America spends on defense. Congress cannot tax their way out of this problem. I will never vote to increase taxes on the hardworking families of Montana.

Congress must focus on cutting the wasteful spending of the bureaucracy. I have a record of cutting spending at the Office of Public Instruction, and Montana voters know that I will bring that fiscal responsibility to the D.C. swamp. Congress can cut the Department of Education, the IRS, the Department of Housing and Urban Development, and the EPA, which has been weaponized against Montana farmers and ranchers. There are many opportunities to cut spending across all the agencies, and I am ready to roll up my sleeves and get to work for Montanans.

Compare to competing candidates
Would you support federal legislation that either restricts abortion access or guarantees access on a national basis? With what conditions?
Elsie Arntzen:

I believe that every life is precious. I will always protect the lives of those who cannot advocate for themselves, the unborn. The Dobbs v. Jackson decision from the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe vs Wade and returned abortion policy back to the states. This decision established that states have the authority to enact restrictions on abortions. Federally, Congress can ensure that tax dollars are not used for abortions by prohibiting funding from going to national and international organizations whose main purpose is promoting and performing abortions.

Compare to competing candidates
What if anything should Congress do to ensure Montanans have access to affordable housing?
Elsie Arntzen:

Much of the housing crisis here is due to misguided policies from the federal government and state regulations. Inflation, mainly caused by out-of-control federal spending and rising energy costs, make it harder to build and maintain housing. Congress must cut regulations that hurt Montana small businesses, our farmers and ranchers, and our ability to build affordable homes. The bureaucracy in D.C knows nothing of the struggles our communities face, instead they restrict the innovation that made America great.

High energy costs burden our businesses and farmers which in turn increases the cost of all necessary goods for Americans. One of the first legislative initiates I would pursue is unleashing American energy potential. Here in Montana, we can lead the way. Congress needs to expand an “all of the above” energy production policy that allows natural gas and oil producers to access and provide these abundant resources to Americans.

Compare to competing candidates
To what extent do you see climate change as an urgent issue? What if any action should Congress take to address it?
Elsie Arntzen:

Far too often the government bureaucracy gives into climate alarmists who present a false choice between a strong economy and a clean environment. In reality, America’s free market has allowed innovation that has made us a leader among nations. Shutting down energy production, like climate activists want, will only hurt American industry and ingenuity. Free market consumer choices should lead rather than the heavy hand of the government. Between the cold weather and long distances in Montana, electric vehicle mandates are not feasible or realistic. Mandating electric vehicles, as the Biden administration has done, will cripple our farmers and fundamentally hurt our ability to grow and transport food.

Rogue nations like China are the true polluters of this world. Yet America buys critical minerals from China instead of accessing the abundance of U.S. resources. America will create jobs through the responsible development of resources, spur innovation, and not use child labor.

Compare to competing candidates
What if any action should Congress take to change how the nation controls movement across the U.S.-Mexico border?
Elsie Arntzen:

Quite frankly, improving our national security along the border and reforming our immigration system is the top priority for Montana and America. Since Joe Biden took office there have been over 7.2 million illegals who invaded the U.S. through our southern border. That number is greater than the population of 36 states. First and foremost, Congress must secure the border by finishing the wall and implementing technologies that will assist our Border Patrol agents. Congress must reauthorize the Remain in Mexico policy put in place by President Trump and end “catch and release.” The backlog in the immigration courts must be addressed so that a free pass isn’t given to criminals, terrorists and drug dealers. Finally, America must deport illegal migrants who have flagrantly broken U.S. law, by dealing drugs, stealing property and assaulting and murdering U.S. citizens.

Compare to competing candidates
The cost of health care is a concern for many Montanans. What if any federal action would you support to improve the U.S. health care system?
Elsie Arntzen:

The government needs to reign in the regulations and strengthen the freedom to choose what health insurance they want. Congress must enact legislation that treats employees the same way as employers. Workers should be able to purchase their own plan with pre-tax dollars and take it with them from job to job. This would be especially beneficial for those later in life when health problems often materialize.

Obamacare’s top-down, one-size-fits-all strategy increased costs, decreased quality and consolidated the health care market, reducing competition and choice for patients. Montanans must be empowered to take control of their health care decisions and allowed to purchase the insurance they want, not the insurance the government dictates to them. Congress must promote transparency in health care price and quality, so families are not surprised by bills. I will work to improve health care access for our rural and aging communities in Montana who are often ignored by D.C. special interests.

Compare to competing candidates

MTFP COVERAGE OF Arntzen

CAMPAIGN FINANCE

Based on reporting required by the U.S. Federal Election Commission. See individual candidate committee pages on the FEC website or the FEC race summary page for more information.
Candidate
Raised
Spent
Remaining
Troy Downing (R)
$1.8M
$1.4M
$435k
Elsie Arntzen (R)
$871k
$805k
$66k
Denny Rehberg (R)
$602k
$454k
$148k
Ed Walker (R)
thru 2024-05-15
$114k
$89k
$25k
Steve Held (D)
thru 2024-05-15
$87k
$68k
$19k
Joel Krautter (R)
$77k
$67k
$9k
Kevin Hamm (D)
$63k
$58k
$5k
Ming Cabrera (D)
thru 2024-05-22
$60k
$41k
$19k
Ken Bogner (R)
$54k
$43k
$11k
Ric Holden (R)
thru 2024-05-15
$49k
$47k
$3k
Stacy Zinn (R)
thru 2024-05-15
$41k
$3k
$38k
Kyle Austin (R)
thru 2024-05-15
$0
$0
$500
The FEC summary page may include candidates who did not file for the ballot in this race with the Montana secretary of state. Additionally, some active candidates may not appear on this list because they are not required to file paperwork with the FEC until they raise or spend $5,000 on their campaigns.

Election outcomes

June 4 primary – Republican candidates
CandidateVotesPercentage
TROY DOWNING36,05036.2%
DENNY REHBERG17,07017.1%
STACY ZINN13,47813.5%
ELSIE ARNTZEN9,3949.4%
KEN BOGNER8,9699.0%
RIC HOLDEN7,0637.1%
JOEL G. KRAUTTER3,4093.4%
KYLE AUSTIN3,1383.1%
ED WALKER1,1521.2%
Count reported by Montana secretary of state as of Jun 10, 2024.

COMMON VOTING QUESTIONS

When are Montana’s 2024 elections?

Voters will pick which candidates advance to the November general election in the June primary, which is scheduled for Tuesday, June 4. Voters will pick the candidates who will ultimately fill each office on the ballot in the November election, which is set for Tuesday, Nov. 5.

Who runs Montana’s elections?

Montana elections are administered at the county level. The process is overseen by county clerks and election administrators, who help to train and monitor the volunteer election judges that staff the polls. Ballots are typically processed and counted at central county locations, with the results reported to the Montana secretary of state’s office via a statewide software system called ElectMT.

Once polls close, the secretary of state’s office provides results through its website. The state-level office also provides guidance to local election administrators to ensure compliance with state election laws. Additionally, enforcing compliance with some laws governing political campaigns, particularly those involving campaign finance, falls to a separate office known as the Commissioner of Political Practices.

Do I need to be registered in order to vote?

Yes. If you’re unsure about your registration status, you can check it through the Montana secretary of state's My Voter Page. You can register to vote by stopping by your county election office any time during regular business hours to pick up an application. After you’ve filled it out, you’ll need to get it back to your county election office by mail or in person (the latter option is strongly recommended close to Election Day to ensure your application is received in time). If you do present your application in person, you’ll have to provide a photo ID or the last four digits of your Social Security number. If you happen to be applying for a Montana driver’s license or identification card before the election, you can register to vote at the same time.

Can I register to vote on Election Day?

Yes. The state Legislature has sought to enact an earlier registration deadline, but under a March 2024 ruling by the Montana Supreme Court, same-day voter registration remains legal in Montana. Residents can register to vote or update their voter registration at their county’s election office prior to 8 p.m. on Election Day.

Does Montana have voter ID requirements?

Yes, you will be required to present identification when voting at the polls. However, under the Montana Supreme Court’s March ruling, changes made to those requirements by the 2021 Legislature remain blocked. The current forms of identification voters can use at the polls are a current Montana driver’s license, state-issued photo ID, tribal or military photo ID, a U.S. passport or a student ID. If you don’t have a photo ID, you can use a utility bill, a bank statement, a voter confirmation card or any other government document that shows your name and address.

Are there situations where I wouldn't be eligible to vote?

According to state law, you can't vote if you'll be under age 18 on Election Day, are not a U.S. citizen, or have lived in Montana less than 30 days. Convicted felons who are currently incarcerated in a penal facility and people whom judges have ruled to be of unsound mind are also ineligible to vote. Otherwise, you're good to go.

Can I vote online?

No, that’s not an option in Montana.

Can I vote by mail?

Yes, you can sign up as an absentee voter by checking a box on your voter registration form. If you’re already registered to vote, you can fill out a separate form and submit it to your county election office.

If you’re registered as an absentee voter, a ballot should be mailed to you a few weeks in advance of each election day. You can make sure your address is current via the My Voter page. County election officials are slated to mail ballots to voters for the June 2024 primary election May 10.

You can return ballots by mail, or drop them off in person at your county’s election office. Either way, the election office must receive your ballot by 8 p.m. on Election Day in order to count it.

How do I vote in person?

If you plan to vote at the polls, just be sure you know where your polling location is and head there between 7 a.m. and 8 p.m. on Election Day. You'll need to provide a photo ID and sign the precinct register, at which point you’ll get your ballot and be directed to a voting booth. If you have any technical questions or run into any problems, the election judges at your polling place should be able to help you.

I have a friend or family member who isn't able to drop off his or her mail-in ballot. Can I do it for them?

Yes, you can. The Montana Legislature did make some changes to ballot collection laws in 2021 related to paid ballot collection, those changes have also been blocked by the Montana Supreme Court.

Who should I vote for?

That’s your call, not ours. We hope the information we present on this guide is helpful as you make that decision for yourself, though.

About this project

This guide was produced by the Montana Free Press newsroom with production and web development by Eric Dietrich, editing by Brad Tyer and Nick Ehli and contributions from Arren Kimbel-Sannit, Mara Silvers, Alex Sakariassen, Amanda Eggert and Stephanie Farmer. Questionnaire responses for legislatiive candidates were collected with help from the Montana League of Women Voters, through the league's Vote 411 program. Contact Eric Dietrich with questions, corrections or suggestions at edietrich@montanafreepress.org.

Montana Free Press is a nonpartisan 501(c)(3) nonprofit, reader-supported news organization serving Montana. MTFP's donor base includes supporters from across Montana's political spectrum, including some Montanans who are candidates in this year's election. MTFP's major donors are listed here and a current list of other supporters is available here. MTFP's news judgments are made entirely independently from donor involvement.

This material is available for republication by other media outlets under Montana Free Press' standard distribution terms.